LAW i think you could have helped your cause by starting the War Thread with an accurate title, and more importantly some waffle for justification of your down hit. We(poo) did a dodgy hit recently and attempted to justify it in the opening post, it gave the community a chance to judge us on our actions...had it bit deemed not good enough the other guilds would step in. Had you started your thread with "We've hit Empire as they've been seen burning and looting in our realms" then i doubt anyone would have said a word.
I felt that POO was stuck in a hard place as we don't want to see how allies wronged and as the big guild in the faith(well i guess just the only other guild) its our duty to step in when faith determines it. Its hard to decipher whats going on with different reasons being thrown about. Doesn't help that Seska's posts tend to be angry anyway, but looking at his RL issues i guess thats no wonder.
Once this shit calms down i'll try and persuade some members of POO to branch off so we can have two guilds back in Leto again.
'cuz those are gonna be outsides!"