Dirtyrat,
A lot of you feedback is not really relating to the recent changes to the UI, and some of it is actually on the roadmap to be changed. Even so, it's always nice to get some general feedback, especially when it comes to usability, that's something that we don't get enough actual feedback on.
A big downside to the feedback that I usually get, is that it's coming from players who already have an expert understanding of how the game works, and so features that are confusing can easily go overlooked.
So, even though this thread was created in order to get feedback on the specific changes implemented in v2.9, I'm going to respond to all your points as they relate to user experience.
Going through your points starting with the old complaints.
Old 1. Integrated vs Separate Message Boards.
Monarchy or Canon (depending on what your referring to as eons ago), has always had a separate message board system, at least as far as I can recall. You've never been able to post from inside the game, and have always had to log into those boards separately.
I do recall a few games from back in the day that had a "fully integrated" board system, but they tended to be home-made boards, and because of that they missed out on a lot of management functionality and security. These are the main reasons to have a separate system for the message boards, that and avoiding spending time rewriting applications that have already been written (and tested) a thousand times over.
The game 'did' used to create you a message board account at the same time as creating a game account (a LONG time ago), but that was when a different board system (that no longer exists) was in use. That was retired back around 2002 or so, when the game switched to phpbb and has remained that way.
That being said, there 'are' ways to integrate your game account with your boards identity, by using the 'Tool' screen, but this is one of the least easy to find parts of the portal, and something that is in need of change. There are also plans to integrate the game and boards much more in the future, specifically with regards to war declarations, help systems and roleplay, but they require a stronger link between game and boards to already be in place.
I actually have already written the basics of a plugin authentication system that would replace the default phpbb authentication with one that combines site and boards, and which would allow a unified account system. However, as phpbb has been quickly developing towards the next major milestone build (3.1), I've held off simply because the new version of phpbb will render the entirety of the code out of date, and I'd shortly be unable to upgrade to a newer better board system without removing the link, or rewriting the entire system from scratch again.
Old 2. Too many graphics.
This is the only part of your post that actually relates to the recent in-game UI changes. Could you be more specific? Are you referring to the navigation icons (which are not actually part of the recent changes, but still comparatively new), or are you referring to the new modular images seem on screens like Hire, War, Sorcery etc?
I'd really appreciate more specific feedback on this point.
Old 3. Inability to backspace into the game.
I tested this out myself and the only time I was able to generate a random error that prevented my progress, was when I tried to backspace on to a page that was the result of submitting a form. The error screen that came up was a default firefox screen, that is aimed to prevent forms being re-submitted.
I have actually vastly improved this system from the old versions of the game, which used forms to navigate between screens. Now, if you backspace to a document expired error screen, you ought to be able to hit backspace again until you finally reach a screen where you didn't submit a form.
In the end, I can't really do anything to prevent you reaching a browser expired page when backspacing to a screen where a form submission occurred. All I can really do is minimise form submissions so that they don't occur during navigation, which I've done.
New 1. Different racial building names is confusing.
While I agree that the majority of other games just use the same names for the same buildings, I actually really like that this game has a lot more variety depending on which race you chose. It's one of those little personalisation touches that makes the game a little more interesting (IMO).
That being said, I can also understand that this might be confusing. We've tried to do our best to reduce confusion in several ways. Firstly we keep a consistent pattern to the buildings (e.g top left is always your income building, top right is always the BRT building etc.). There is also consistency in the icon for each building type, and also a short description under each building of what it does.
Other than renaming all the buildings to be the same for each race (which is not on the cards), I can think of a couple of minor tweaks we can do to make the process a bit clearer, but I am more than happy to hear suggestions.
New 2. Information on Racial differences
When you create a kingdom there is - between the dropdown for selecting a god, and the submit button - a link called 'Race Stats' that takes you to a page that give an overview of the various differences between the races. The same information can be accessed via the portal 'Game Information' -> Gods & Races -> {game name} Race and Troop Info, and in game by using the 'Troop Stats' icon situation in the footer.
I agree that this information could be easier to find, and it's something that's on the things to do list when I recreate the kingdom creation system. This UI overhaul is planned to cover the entire game portal and creation process, I just started with the game itself.
New 3. Storyline
I'm glad you like the basics of the storyline
New 4. Limited Game Mechanics / Community
On the subject of the game choices being limited to hire, train, build and attack I guess your right. But there is a lot of strategic variation between those choices. I'm not really sure what else could be added without a massive overhaul of the way the game works. The other common game options in games of this genre are a research option which generally boosts player stats and attack option, or a trading option.
I've considered a trading system in the past, but to be honest, unless you add a secondary purpose for tradeable resources then the system becomes pointless, and you're just trading for the sake of trading. A research option is another thing that would hugely impact the dynamic of the game, and adds a layer of complexity that I'm not sure is really required. I personally think that simplicity in the base game, combined with a variety of strategic options creates a better game.
I am open to ideas for other mechanisms that can be added into the mix, but am mindful of avoiding losing the core concept and feel of how the game plays.
That said, I am currently working on the concept for a 'Leader' screen, where you can personalise your strengths (and weaknesses) beyond the differences you get by selecting a different race. I am also working on a selection of new options for the War and Sorcery screens.
Regarding the importance of community, historically these message boards have always been a critical component of the overall way the game worked from a political and roleplay point of view. Unfortunately, these days, new players tend to consider message boards to be an optional part of the gaming process, and many people register an account without ever visiting the boards. I have ideas for how to try and push new players towards the boards more, but they really require the greater integration that I mentioned in a previous response.
New 5. Kingdom Death
There are a selection of features that have been added over the years in order to mitigate this. They include methods to prevent declaring war on smaller kingdoms, meaning that you can only hit a smaller kingdom 3 times, and then cannot continue because you cannot declare war. We also have added a Restore feature, that you can use after being attacked or killed, and restore back to a previous state of your kingdom rather than having to restart from scratch
New 6. Basic vs Complex
I'm not really sure if you think that this game is too basic or too complex, so am not really sure how to reply to this. Personally I think this game is basic on the surface, but complex strategically. However I think that it can 'seem' more complex than it actually is, due to a lack of a decent help system (another thing that's being worked on).