Page 1 of 3
v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 10:04 pm
by Kaz
This forthcoming reset (Between 28th July and 4th Aug 2013) will see the roll out of v2.5
This thread is for ideas I'm considering for version 2.6, which wont roll out for a couple of months time (end of September start of October, barring unforeseen circumstances).
If you feel the need to post a different suggestion you can, as long as you stop trying to argue the case if I say your suggestion is not feasible at this time. This thread isn't about 'pushing' your ideas, its about discussion of mine ;p
Anyway, on to the things I want to discuss
1.
End of RPP. As it currently stands the end of RPP is out of your control. I'm going to say now, that I don't like that, and that it defeats the objective of RPP being a positive experience for the player restoring. You need to pick an 'end time' 2 days in advance, and have to hope you'll be online. If you can't get to the computer on the turn of the hour, then you can just get mashed before you even play a turn out of RPP.
I want to discus ideas for how to put control over the end of RPP back in the hand of the player who's restoring.
Current ideas include a flag that triggers ending RPP the first time the player logs into the kingdom after RPP ends. Down sides I can see to that idea are that you could essentially restore and then not log in again and remain invulnerable.
Another idea would be a way of the player manually extending or reducing RPP duration when nearing the end of RPP, so that they can modify the end time. This might be quite hard to engineer and still requires the player to predict their ability to access the game at a very specific `future` time.
Maiking RPP a set number of turns might be the easiest way. It would essentially mean rewriting the system, but I know how it would work and I could just use the same kingdom variable in a slightly different way. But that's got the same invulnerability issue.
Perhaps turns mixed with a maximum duration. I dunno. Discuss
2.
Open Acres. Many years ago, kingdoms with lots of open acres were seen as a bad thing. However, building strategies and practice with larger kingdoms has changed this. Now, the top of the scrolls are often mostly open acres with hardly any intent by the player to actually build up the entire kingdom. Essentially most large kingdoms now actually take 'more' land before they've finished building what they took before.
I want to discuss ideas for an attack type (war, scum or sorc), that is specifically aimed at destroying 'open' land. The option would most likely be called something like 'salt the earth'. I'm personally leaning towards a new war screen option where maximum failure still has 'some' positive result, but am not really sure how I want to implement it. Sorcery would be easier to implement, but we've just boosted the sorcery options and there are comparatively less war options.
I'm open to suggestions.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 10:14 pm
by Gili
1. I got caught out with this. I hit restore with the full intention of being online in 72 hours(or 48...whatever it is), and then was too busy. Next morning i was trashed again. Shouldn't complain too much, as i had a extra chance at getting it right, which we never had before.
As to a suggestion towards this, perhaps a period of 48 hours of enforced RPP, and then you can come out of that any time within 24 hours after. That way 72 hours you get kicked out of rpp anyway.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Thu Aug 01, 2013 11:21 pm
by Darnivan
1) You could make it a slightly longer period like 54 hours and give them a "leave restore protection early" button the last 6 hours. That would give them some leeway and be able to use their turns before getting crushed like your droben just was without too many ways to abuse it.
2) As far as open acres it has always been an end of age thing. Big kingdoms don't have the economy to really use all those acres, so most of the age you want to stay relatively lean to get as much built as you can but as the end of the age gets near you just want to mass as many acres as you can to max your networth potential and no longer bother with building. An attack that just targets open acres sounds neat but would only be used the last few weeks of the age and if it can be used with a measure of success against someone no matter what the power difference is it would be a dangerous tool for abuse (think a dauthi style player that just salted earth on the largest kingdoms all age, no real war just harassment). It would become very frustrating to deal with...Maybe if that minimum damage was only like 0.5% or less of open acres so if you only had a reasonable 10k open it would only do 50 acres of damage but if you had my goblin kingdom with 169k open acres it would destroy 845 acres.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 1:52 am
by Dauthi
Not sure if this is a bug or needs to be suggested but.
"Top 20 Turns Absorbed Avg"
You can't be ranked on this till you are killed, that doesn't make sense. If I manage to keep myself alive(or not use restore), and take over 1k turns, I'm averaging 1k turns absorbs per life, not 0.
Another thing would be, if a player/NPC hits the restore button(NPC's hit restore correct? cause I've knocked a few down to come back in 24-48 hrs to have them rebuilt back close to what they were before), have this count as a kill.
Reasoning: You can't always kill someone with a full set of turns, -but- you knock them down to 60/hit or something and they hit restore before you get more turns and all the time you've spent on them is waisted.
I realize that I'm probably one of the only players who actually uses the alternative ranking screen as a way to see MY success, but I think if Restore counted toward kills, and turns absorbed was fixed it would make bring a little more interest to that portion of the game in general.
As for your suggestion -
1. Make coming out of RPP cost turns. 25 turns or something. You can sit in RPP as long as you want, but can't come out till you've spend 25 turns. Then make it so RPP realms can't ally up with anyone in the game so that they can't share money or troops, and after 48 hrs, their build rate/income is cute in half. So yes if they want to sit in RPP and build up their realm before coming out they can, but it will be slower and with less benefit, it also allows players who after getting their first 150 turns to jump back into the war with out having to spend turns building up cause of a set time frame.
2. Salt the land - would be a great sorcery thing. it targets open land and makes them unusable.
As for a Scum option, "Build Traps" - The idea is that your army sneaks into their open land, and builds traps on them and then retreats. Once they use turns the traps go off, killing troops and salting the earth(small amount salted then the sorc option).
As for War opition, like CS is for x amount of land aimed at weakening their troops, have it so you can aim for the open acres. using the CS formula for war, with an additional bonus of killing peasants and taking ONLY open acres.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 2:32 am
by Blacklock
1) I like the idea of being able to come out when you want, have turn rate decrease on a scale until 0 the longer you stay in? This way its not just a set amount of turns and if for some reason you want to sit there your not able to just build forever.
2) I like this, but I agree with Darnivan it should be a small percentage.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 1:44 pm
by Kaz
I wrote up a post answering dauthi and it doesn't look like I actually posted it.
I'll write it up again in a bit, but the average turns absorbed will show the correct (absorb / (deaths+1)) rathe than (absorb / deaths) next age.
With regards to leaving RPP ideas.
- Gradually reduce Turn Rate until leave RPP
- Cost 25 turns to leave RPP
Those two ideas - although good - leave a scenario where a player can get huge, get mashed, restore to a reasonably decent kingdom, if large enough to start with, maybe even retain the King spot after reforting. Then stop playing, be invincible and get a HoF medal or achievement.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 2:55 pm
by Jokingjoe
RPP: I kind of like the extended 54 hour idea, but you can leave when you want after 48. It would almost give you the ability of the old "vacation mode" which I sometimes miss when I'm out of town.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 4:42 pm
by Kaz
On the RPP front
Darnivan's suggestion of 54 hours and leave 6 hours early is essentially the same as Gili's idea. Just phrased differently and with a different length of 'Optional RPP'
48 hours RPP plus 6 hours of leave time vs. 48 hours of RPP plus 24 hours of leave time.
It's probably the easiest option to impliment without the issues of invincibility mode.
2x config values : Enforced RPP duration & Optional RPP duration.
Longer choice gives more freedom.
For example, with Gili's suggestion you can chose to enter RPP at 2am on a Saturday night/sunday morning, and still exit on your terms at some point on Tuesday, but would be forced out at 1am Wednesday morning. 6 hours means you have to find a way to be online between 1am and 7am Tuesday morning.
On the side of part 2,
Darnivan, you havn't been in what I'd consider a 'built' state, since the 5th of july (half way through the age). Since that time you've fluctuated between 30% and 70% open land, generally around the 50% level.
I'm not looking for an attack mode that's easy, just something that's worthwile.
845 acres out of 169,000 open acres is nothing. Especially if, to destroy that, the kingdom has lost 50% of thier troops a hit (like with maximum fail FS).
It would be a hugely expensive guild-wide operation just to remove open land from your kingdom, and you'd still have all the troops and scum until you next log in.
Even after losing every bit of open land, logging, in and reworking troops. You'd still be an 85,000 acre fully built kingdom.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 4:43 pm
by Kaz
Dauthi,
NPC's don't restore. If an NPC seems to have restored, that's because somebody killed it, and the system put it back out with a new build.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 4:47 pm
by Jokingjoe
hehe,Dauthi--that was probably me KSing your NPC kills

Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 6:25 pm
by Dauthi
Kaz,
Thanks for changing the turn absorb thing.
As for the RPP - how about this. 48 hrs(or what ever it is) 25 turns gets you another 24 hrs, and the option to leave anytime you want in them 24 hrs.
Also can we get restores to count as kills(kill goes to the person who attacked them last)?
Joe,
are you #12 from the angie faith? *shakes fist at you* stealing my kills, why not just come to the dark side?
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 7:05 pm
by Kaz
Not sure that we need player to 'pay' to have choice in the end restore time.
In the post I lost, I mentioned that next age restores would could as kills (for the purposes of scores).
Kills in the context of bounties is another thing. If I implemented it, it wouldn't just based on the last hit. Someone could essentially just farm those bounties by quickly hitting a realm that's been mashed by someone else, and is likely to restore.
It's actually a lot more complicated though, as the bounty screen uses a tracking table that currently has nothing at all to do with the restore process. I might be able to implement something, but I think I'd pick the 'killer' based on damage caused over the duration of the restore window.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 9:08 pm
by Darnivan
From my point of view the age was over by then, we only really had end of age faith wars left. I didn't downsize because I was saving up for the end and I wasn't sure how scarce land would be from then on since we would have a hard time making any offensive wars. : ) At that point I had only 30% open there was a moderately high chance that I would be able to build that before we could war again.
It was a bit earlier than normal as far at timing, but Angelique had an insurmountable lead as long as we kept playing the game. The age wasn't declared over, but the conclusion was known.
And my point with the "salt earth" or as I like to call it "pillage countryside" was you said it did a MINIMUM damage. That means it would do that damage with 1 green footsoldier against my kingdom with over 55k elite trolls and 5500 forts. I think over 800 acres would be more than fair in that case : )
More troops can do more damage, but a tiny kingdom shouldn't be able to take out 100k acres with 1 green footsoldier. That was all I was thinking : ) Even with my suggestion they would be able to take out like 20k acres with a kingdom that I have more trolls than they have peasants : )
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 10:19 pm
by Kaz
Yeah it's not really any different to the same sort of losses from sorcery and 1 temples, but I had thought about the 1 green footsoldier scenario. But I've got a couple of months to work it out.
It could work differently and be partially based on number of troops used in comparison to the troop cap. if you use 1% of your troops cap, then you do 1% of the minimum damage, but if you're using 100% of your troop cap, and losing a lot of troops, you do something worthwhile, even at maximum loss.
After all, 1 green footsolder, can hardly salt 800 acres of land on his own.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 10:39 pm
by Darnivan
Yeah, that would make it make more sense if they actually have to put effort into buying troops as they go to do damage rather than just hitting with nothing.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2013 11:06 pm
by Aeropagitica
Be wary of overcomplicating the game. Though I do distinctly recall recommending that forcing a player to restore should increment a 'kill' last age. As for having excessive unbuilt land, what about pairing taxes; the more unbuilt land you have (%), the higher your expenses. The more acres/forts you have, the less defense your forts offer. Rather than implement a direct attack against players with large swaths of unbuilt land, why not just tax them and give them passive penalties to deal with like those aforementioned.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Sat Aug 03, 2013 1:49 pm
by Kaz
I 'am' weary of over complicating the game, but at the moment I'm also acutely aware that with a smaller player-base, winners of the first war or two can essentially dominate throughout the age.
This effect is not so bad when there are lots of first wars, and lots of guilds from different faiths getting that early jump. They get to fight each other, and the process works with guilds moving up and down all over the scrolls throughout the age.
However, with 1 or 2 guilds per faith it becomes easy for a faith to dominate early on and become uncatchable within current means. This is going to become boring fast, for all involved.
Tax-wise, I'd argue that a process that kicks in to tax kingdoms with large percentages of open land, would be adding far more complication, than a new war attack that specifically targets open acres. You have large sections of open land immediately after a tithe, and so there would have to be lots of rules to prevent that process being effected.
The suggestion of unbuilt land increasing expenses is a good idea in theory, but would mean a total rework of the economy formulas to convert open land from a positive to a negative. That's something which I try to avoid doing as much as possible, and when I do change something, it's generally within historic boundaries. Our economy equations are highly complex, and so many other games fail miserably to get one that works as well as ours does. It's very easy to have two similar kingdoms with millions of difference in networth. With our system, the economy changes are actually extremely gradual.
Forts offering less defence, makes sense from a realism perspective. But it would be pretty complicated to implement, and would effect all attacks. It would be a far larger change than simply adding a new attack type that is only really useful in certain scenarios. It also wouldn't actually add any real bonus towards the changes needed, because if you could break the kingdom anyway, you'd be wanting to take the land for yourself.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Sat Aug 03, 2013 6:51 pm
by Gili
How about un-built land not being apart of the "troop cap" formula? Is that easier
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Sun Aug 04, 2013 6:20 am
by Jokingjoe
Kaz said:
Kills in the context of bounties is another thing. If I implemented it, it wouldn't just based on the last hit. Someone could essentially just farm those bounties by quickly hitting a realm that's been mashed by someone else, and is likely to restore.
That's true--but as Dauthi and I would add..many of our legit kills come from doing just that--housekeeping after another player has done most of the work.
Dauthi:
I try to make a balance of things. I like to play for kills, but I also enjoy "growing" the kingdom. My strat last age was to, upon hitting 10k built, war on NPCs during peace and downsize all open so that I'd never have to build again. I was able to do that pretty well and I was the "easy" target of the guild, so the enemy wasted hundreds of scum/sorc turns on me rather than my royal kin up top. The kin would exact revenge on my aggressors, and I would happily "mop up" doing what I enjoy most.
Re: v2.6 tweak ideas
Posted: Sun Aug 04, 2013 10:47 am
by Kaz
There's a difference between making a kill by attacking a kingdom multiple times until it's dead, and making a single 'last hit' to tag a kingdom that's clearly going to restore, and claim bounties as if you'd done some work.