Page 1 of 2

UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 6:23 pm
by Aeyliea
I would love to do something at the moment, Kaz. Thanks Igneous, for that unwelcome present....again. I suppose the goal is to open me up for Duathi to finish me off again.

We'll see what happens, since only the two realms you declared on can do anything to you. You are unfortunately safe from the rest of the guild, under the UG Protection coding -.-

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 6:36 pm
by Igneous
You're welcome. Nah, any involvement from anyone else is coincidental. God bless the Monarchy rule of law and the Unguildeds Protection Act. I just know you'll smash me good, that is all I came for. :-)

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 8:25 pm
by Kaz
UG Protection coding
???

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 8:36 pm
by Igneous
A.K.A The U.P.A.

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 8:44 pm
by Kaz
Kaz wrote:
UG Protection coding
???
Igneous wrote:A.K.A The U.P.A.
What??

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 8:50 pm
by Igneous
I'm not quite sure exacly, .... Aey?

I just thought my term sounded more official.

Poor little unguildeds....

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 9:12 pm
by Gili
Isn't he referring to that we can't down hit UG's? Or we can only hit 3 times and such?

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 10:04 pm
by Kaz
Gili wrote:Isn't he referring to that we can't down hit UG's? Or we can only hit 3 times and such?
That's exactly the same for guilded kingdoms too so I don't really see why that's specifically 'UG' protection coding. Plus isn't it the case that some of the big kingdoms are UG's at the moment? If that's the case the down-hit declaration code wouldn't prevent attacking 'them'.

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 10:37 pm
by Aeropagitica
Just hypothetical and all...as an unguilded, could I kill the king, take his robes, and declare victory for myself?! ;)

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 10:39 pm
by Darnivan
Yeah, there is literally 1 (enemy) kingdom in the game that can't declare on the big 4 :)

Though those 4 are large enough to give the guilds a pretty good fight. I bet if they hit first they could probably have a fair chance beating one of the guilds.

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2013 10:47 pm
by Igneous
Aero, you aren't king yet?! What's taking so long?

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:33 am
by Aeyliea
It don't matter, I can break a fucking 11K unguilded because he can hide below larger realms then suisorc even on a goblin and destroy any ability of mine to retalliate.

I meant the Unguilded Protection Act, which prevents people from preventing suicide realms from doing whatever they please. Pretty much what has been happening to me since that one war we're not going to speak of.

I might be able to do something about the whole thing if preserve BRT wasn't in effect - all that does is make it take less actions to comp-letely destroy a realms effectiveness to wage war, same as being hit down by war leaves you with nothing but quarries, removing you from a war pretty effectively.

Its ok though. I know how I will handle this situation.

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Tue Mar 05, 2013 1:48 am
by Jokingjoe
That's right..get Dauthi..don't look at me ;)

Re: Numbers (split from politics)

Posted: Tue Mar 05, 2013 9:59 pm
by Nagash
Aeyliea wrote:I meant the Unguilded Protection Act, which prevents people from preventing suicide realms from doing whatever they please. Pretty much what has been happening to me since that one war we're not going to speak of.
As suicide realms cannot do downhitting declares either, what damage can they do if you fort properly? Pretty much the same goes for Goblins. They rarely have more than 3k acres. Get 250 forts and they can't do shit.

Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2013 12:00 am
by Aeyliea
That is not the case Nagash. Suicide realms do not generally attack via war - they use sorc. A good suicide realm has a ridiculous % temples, and can do what is called 'power sorcing' - IE, no scout, no burn. That is NOT what the person attacking me did - they took advantage of the fact that the realm they focused on is a weak scum race, burned, and lotted me. They were and probably will continue power sorcing through my other realm as they can - and they are using a race that is, on the whole, ineffective at sorc.

A 6K UG could level just about anyone they please as much as 2-5 times their size, and in many cases MUCH larger since not all people build a set % of temples.

This case is not one of those, but I am sure such occurances will be coming my way eventually.

The point of this game is its Guilds. Not COnquest, not Domination, not Bloodbath. Guilds People outside of guilds should not be afforded protection because htey are small. I grant that there are new players who really are only unguilded because they don't know about it, but others - with far more experience - can abuse this protection horribly.

Lets take an example here. Lets say, for the sake of argument, UG A has an 8K acre kingdom....with 6K temples on it. UG A is either mad at Guilded A, or is simply taking advantage of the no downhit coding to do step 2.

UG A declares on Guilded !, 8K acres versus 27K acres. Guilded A has 3K temples. Guilded A gets completely lotted.

The Guild in questions' smallest realm is 11K acres. The only person who can make war offensive actions is Guilded A because only Guilded A was declared on, and UG A is too small for anyone in The Guild to declare on. UG A is smart, and spends some turns building forts on his sorc battery kingdom on the land opened by backlash and sacrifice. Guilded A, with few to no buildings beyond quarries, cannot fortifiy offense without spending inordinate amounts of turns doing it, and inordinate amounts of cash. All the remaining realms in The Guild can only either scumkill at great cost, burn at great cost, or each take 3 and out CS1s or FAs on UG A. So yes, guilds CAN deal with unguildeds, but at an EXTREME disadvantage.

Now add into the mix that UG A's sole goal was to lot Guilded A, and the loss of their kingdom is taken as given and therefore unimportant. UG A dies, restarts as a new kingdom, rinse, repeat.

Catching them before they act is tough. If your smallest realm is 11K and you are tyring to burn an UG suicide realm, it will cost boatloads of turns per burn for even the 11K acre realm, let alone larger realms. Even scouting them costs a lot of turns. And if you do find them, your options are burn or scumkill, which becomes pointless because they will or can just do it over and over again.

Now, if you really want it to get interesting, and someone is willing to do the math and work, an unguilded could wreck pretty much anyone with impunity depending on their race.

And once again, I reitterate: This is the guilds game. If you want to play as UG in guilds, fine, but you shouldn't be protected for it.

Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2013 3:05 am
by Igneous
Hi.

Poor little unguildeds......

God bless the Monarchy rule of law and the

Unguildeds Protection Act.

Three and outs by an entire guild should wreck any small threat in my opinion.

Faith based war game favors the devout who honor their beloved deity with the sacrifice of building a percentage of their land in architecture that focuses on that commitment..... Odd....

Guild leadership does have a difficult responsibility to assess all threats and keep them at bay. When they are able. Unguildeds are just one category of the many threats they try to remain in controll of.

Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2013 3:28 am
by Aeropagitica
So do we have an issue with suicide sorc realms? I would think, at least with the current build/loss code, such a kingdom could not protect it's land, and 3 and out would quickly eat up all the temples with no quick way of recovering, as <2000 quarry on 8k land is only a mid-tier build rate.
Surely, such a kingdom can kill...but there is no future in it. It's just a war-spite move.

I'm not sure I'm tracking all this UG protection stuff. The same rules that protect UGs also leave them exposed. My Unguildedness this age is merely an experiment (never done it before).

I say utilize your guild. Post those UG #s on the banner and declare open season. In the end, if you live by the sword, you die by the sword.

Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2013 3:46 am
by Igneous
Well said, well said.

Are you king yet?

Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2013 9:02 am
by Nagash
I can see Aeyliea's point when it comes to sorc. As Dauthi/Goblins just does war, he's mostly harmless. With the current no-downhitting code in place, any (group of) unguilded(s) can do quite some damage if they have a scummer by their side. Guilds are busy warring each other or building, so the unguilded can build up and stay under the radar. Then they single out one realm, do sorc damage and either go for the kill or wait for downsizing/dropped defenses.

With no anti-downhitting code one could render such unguildeds useless without too much cost of turns by declaring on them and slapping them about a bit. Now declaring is impossible and three hits will cost a major amount of turns, especially at 3 turns/hour.

Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)

Posted: Wed Mar 06, 2013 11:52 am
by Gili
Exactly. I'm happy for UG's to have their fun, but please disable the downhit protection. If nothing else it might urge them to guild themselves up? Even a guild of 2 is fairly close to some we have