Page 1 of 2
What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2013 6:05 pm
by Kaz
I created a thread like this in the build up to guilds going live. Unfortunately there was not a huge response to the thread and we ended up with pretty much default settings. This is your second chance to give your opinion, It'd be nice to see everyone post.
Once new feature that ought to be in place next age is the ability to restore your kingdom to one you had 72 hours earlier. This restore will delete 75% of the land and buildings and will start you with zero gold and zero troops. This feature
IS going in next age, so it's something to consider when making choices on the other options.
These are the current settings
http://www.monarchygame.com/gameinfo.php?game=guilds
Any of them can be changed.
Most settings are pretty self evident, but I'll post a quick explanation of the ones that might not be so obvious.
Maximum Kingdom Size without War : This setting basically limits how much land your kingdom can tithe for, the top end is close to the maximum the system would actually give you, although the last 20% or so becomes inefficient to actually waste money on.
CURRENTLY this is set to 30k-normal which is the level that was traditionally used by the Guilds game at Evernight. 60k is similar to the settings used by Valid and Maxim at Evernight, 85k is similar to the setting used by the Massacre games.
- - titheland reduces from 21 to 4 over the course of getting each of the different 'gifts' from offering money for land
- There is also a racial modifier
- There is a large modifier that kicks in if you have 50% temples
- There are two other land-based modifiers that gradually reduce as your land increases
Essentially when you tithe the system loops adding a certain amount until the money you've offered equals a goal.
That amount is based on the variables previously mentioned.
The different tithepool options reduce the land-based variables at different speeds and at different amounts of land.
The options configured include 85k, 60k and 30k (based on the amount of land where they've pretty much reduced down to nothing). The 30k land setting also has options configured to count down faster or slower.
Setting can be set to: 30k-slow, 30k-normal, 30k-fast, 60k or 85k
Preserve Build Rate: This setting can either be set to on or off. When turned on the system will reduce BRT generating building slower than other buildings. Basically this means that when losing land or being levelled by sorcery, other buildings will be destroyed more frequently that BRT buildings. The end result meaning that the kingdom retains a higher BRT and can use that to rebuild quicker after the attacks.
- Setting can be set to: On (True) or Off (False)
Prevent Downhits: This setting effects the ability to declare Kingdom vs Kingdom war. It has no effect on the ability to attack other kingdoms, even when turned on a large kingdom can attack a small kingdom until they get the warmonger message. What this setting does is limit the ability to use the alliances screen to 'declare' war. When at war you can make as many hits as you like, so this setting basically prevents more than 3 down-hits from occurring each day.
- The ability to declare war when this setting is turned on comes mostly down to a comparison between the land values of the two kingdoms. If the defending kingdom has AT LEAST 90% of the land total of the attacking kingdom, then the war declaration is allowed.
If the war declaration is not allowed, the system will make two further checks. The first checks to see if the defending kingdom has attacked the attacking kingdom recently, the other check looks to see if the defending kingdom has a greater networth than the attacking kingdom. If none of these are true, the system wont let the war declaration take place.
Setting can be set to: On (True) or Off (False)
Although I've described three options, we can change ANY of the options from the other link. E.g. NPC's on or off, the size of the NPC's, whether the NPC's are in guilds, turns per hour, max turns etc etc. I was just describing the three options that are less easy to understand.
LIST OF SETTINGS THAT CAN BE CHANGED
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2013 6:23 pm
by Aeyliea
Max Tithe: 30K normal
Preserve BRT? No.
Prevent Downhits? No.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2013 6:51 pm
by Kaz
Don't forget that ANY of those options can be changed. I just described the three that are hard to understand at a glance at the list.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Thu Feb 21, 2013 12:10 am
by Aeyliea
Add bounties too, but do not make turns available as a bounty

Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Thu Feb 21, 2013 6:18 am
by Dauthi
I want turns as a bounty.
I would have 432 extra turns if I could have turns as a bounty.
Instead I'm going to cash it all in on elan, and have 38,960 elan.
I wonder if announcing that will make me more of a target... *ponders*
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Thu Feb 21, 2013 6:45 am
by Igneous
The only things I would like more than the current settings are:
6.25 turns per hour.... I like hitting turn cap every 24hrs.
Turn on all bounty options.... Bounties are awesome!
Turn off all npc's... Or keep them tiny. I dont like them.
As player base grows, one kingdom per player is enough, but for now this is kinda fun, keeps things rolling and all....
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Thu Feb 21, 2013 10:39 pm
by Maverick
No bounty on turns.
As for settings Im fine with the current ones. I think most people are just getting a feel for the game still so it may not be an age or 2 until people actually know what they want changed.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Fri Feb 22, 2013 9:51 am
by Venus
yeah its hard for me to choose something when im just getting started again...so i dunno yet what i want....
i wouldnt mind a faith board though? like we used to have? so all the barnabas gms are in one place and easier to find:>
i know that doesnt apply here, but im really really sleepy and just had the thought.
if we cant have one thats ok:> just an idea to keep us in touch easier....
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 12:27 am
by Aeropagitica
I'm a big traditionalist, but as I told you last year, I'm cool with whatever so long as you don't change rules mid-age.
I do have a couple gems to consider: We've heard both yea and nay for turn-based bounty rewards. Consider this: If we do not activate turn based bounties, we're decreasing the incentive for the bottom feeders to try to climb the ranks. Turn bounties are a great way of catapulting yourself back into a competitive range later game. Those who simply are not interested will just use the bounty to keep killing and downsizing, so it really doesn't affect their gamestyle/play. So I suggest having turn bounties active.
I am torn on the high build rate option. I like how it can enable you to more quickly jump back after a beat down, but Ayleia's right...it makes it near impossible to counterattack if you've taken more than 30% dmg. So I have to vote for realism: high buildrate off.
I have never been a sorcerer, but it seems there should be a non-war benefit to going heavy temples. I vote to have temple-tithe modifier on.
Despite your attempts to control the races, people are still using stored builds to pick their preferred race. To keep it fair and balanced, I vote to enable all races.
The Quad war option in guild games over-complicates the issue and can compromise guild loyalty. I do not see the benefit in the guild game, at least not at our current numbers. I vote no Quad War option.
Super-guilds threaten the integrity of the game, positioning every war to be a faith war. As stated earlier, I vote for a population cap on Guild size as a proportion to the total faith population pool [1:2, or 3:5).
For diversity and to promote less aggressive players need to expand with less drama/conflict, NPC Realms = yes. Current strength ratios are satisfactory.
All other options, I do not feel overly moved to change.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 1:14 am
by Calen
I would have to agree with Aero. Also, would like to see the max turns be 250 with 8 turns an hour. If I recall, this was the setting for turns when I first started playing Monarchy but, hey, its been over ten years.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 1:02 pm
by Kaz
Aero (and Calen based on posting you agree)
This thread is about the settings that are configurable and listed on the settings page I linked to. Half of the stuff you posted I'm not sure what setting you're actually referring to, and other bits require recoding. This isn't a recode suggestions thread. I'm currently only interested in settings that can actually be changed without a recode. I've got enough new features to get finished before next age as it is.
High Buildrate : Off - I have no idea what you're talking about here. I would guess you're talking about recoding BRT.
Temple-Tithe Modifier : Off - I have no idea what you're talking about here. I would guess you're talking about recoding tithe modifiers.
Guild Size as a proportion of faith : This is not a currently available configuration setting. A specific numerical maximum might be possible within current code framework.
All Races Available : This is not something that's listed in the 'List of Settings that can be changed' thread.
Basically the only parts of your post that have relevance as far as the existing options I was asking about, are:
Quads: Off
NPC's: On
Bounties: All
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:05 pm
by Darnivan
I think by high build rate he meant the Preserve Build Rate setting, that is what the context sounds like to me.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 9:22 pm
by Maverick
Turn based bounties are to powerful. The button was incredibly powerful, imagine if a kingdom was sitting on 500 turns of bounties?
That being said, while the game is small we should probably remove the "killers" from scoreboard otherwise its way to easy to find out who committed kills.
Calen,
The turn rate has never been 8 and the max turns have never been 250.
The original game was 2 turns per hour, max turns 125.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sun Feb 24, 2013 8:13 am
by Dauthi
Nooooooo, don't remove Killers from the rankings.
Cause thats the only reason I play, I want to be top killer, I don't care about rank or anything else like, but I play to be top killer in this game.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sun Feb 24, 2013 1:33 pm
by Aeropagitica
Maverick wrote:
Calen,
The turn rate has never been 8 and the max turns have never been 250.
The original game was 2 turns per hour, max turns 125.
Mav speaks the truth.
And the turn kill bounty...Most people collect few kills over the course of the game because of the cost-prohibitiveness. Apart from Dauthi, who has collected any realistic number of kills?
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sun Feb 24, 2013 5:26 pm
by Kaz
Removing the score board wouldn't make it less hard to figure out who made kills. That can be done directly from the bounty screen anyway. Just type in a kingdom number and search. It'll tell you if they killed you or not.
Secret kills are no longer possible, and as there is no positive reason at all to have the ability, they won't be returning. Even with all bounties turned off, the ability to search kills remains. All secret kills do is piss off the player that was killed.
You can freely loot the hell out of a kingdom unseen, you can burn the hell out of them unseen, you can kill so many peasants that the next person to attack kills them as a side effect. But if you want to make the kill, then you need to take into consideration that you might be unseen, but you wont be unknown.
Feel free to open a separate thread to discuss the implications of this, but the kill search function is here to stay.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sun Feb 24, 2013 8:41 pm
by Aeyliea
Let me add some more here lol
Turn Bounties - no way jose. Let me explain a little something, and it pains me a great deal to spell it out since its my ace in the hole in Bloodbath.
There are NPCs in Guilds. Sorc killing NPCs is extremely easy, and you gain a bounty from doing so. In bloodbath, I sit on a 11K acre realm intentionally, and farm bounties on NPCs for as much as two weeks at a time. Once I collect enough, I destroy every single living thing above me in the ranks - AKA, everyone. It doesn't matter how big you are, how well forted, how well built. It doesn't matter if you're running 30% forts and 100% scum. You are fucking dead, period.
Turn bounties in guilds would take longer to aquire, but the end result is the same. Guild wars would be an absolute farce - you'd absolutely destroy your opponent in one night, and that would be that. They wouldn't be wars, they'd be massacres.
Who wants to play a game where there is no such thing as a defender, and where in one night, or a few hours, you'll have to start completely over.
That being said.
If you want turn bounties, turn rate needs to be increased to make rebuilding faster OR NPCs need to be configured to carry little to no turns (in the guilds game only!). The reason its ok to gather turns that way in bloodbath is the simple fact that you get 300 turns a day anyway, and it takes as little as a few days to get back into the swing of things. Not so in guilds, where it can take 2-3 weeks to have a solid kingdom again - solid as in 20K+, where in mid-age and later 11-15K acre realms aren't worth as much as larger are. If NPCs had 10-30 turns left on them as a rule within the guilds game, it makes the cost to aquire and store those turns considerably higher than the overall benefit. Some will gain bounties that way, but most bounties will be aquired from killing player characters, not defenseless and turn fat NPCs

Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sun Feb 24, 2013 9:01 pm
by Sikil
Like I said, it's been 10 years or so since I've played so forgive my memory.
But that being said, I would like to see a turn per hour increase next age.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Sun Feb 24, 2013 11:21 pm
by Aeropagitica
I do not think NPC kills should yield any bounty.
Re: What settings shall we use for Guilds next age?
Posted: Mon Feb 25, 2013 2:44 am
by Aeyliea
Or NPC bounties can only be cash, elan, or land. Those are powerful enough bounties for any kill in guilds, turns is crazy.