UG Protection (split from numbers)
Moderators: Staff, Game Staff
- Kaz
- Administrator
- Posts: 2614
- Joined: Thu Sep 24, 2009 1:27 am
- Location: The Vinyards of Fernabergia
- Tempers Ball Posts: 3873
- Tempers Ball/Braggarts Hall Alt: Kaz
- Contact:
Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)
Just to clarify, is this thread complaining about UG's 'are' doing? or just worrying about what UG's 'might' do at some point in the future?
Programming is 10% science, 25% ingenuity and 65% getting the ingenuity to work with the science
Wars of Tonan (Monarchy Inspired Miniatures)
Armatures for Sculpting Miniatures
Wars of Tonan (Monarchy Inspired Miniatures)
Armatures for Sculpting Miniatures
Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)
Fairly sure that earlier in the age Duathi was beating on the BaN whipping boy (Ricardo) and i couldn't really do fuck all about it. Mind you, so far whenever i've said shit...i've been proved wrong.
My only point is, if an UG takes action against a guilded player...the entire guild should be able to retaliate without any kind of limit/protection.
*edit* or was that someone else. Fairly sure some UG ( duathi = goblins) was pounding away on someone and i couldn't declare. Damn memory!
My only point is, if an UG takes action against a guilded player...the entire guild should be able to retaliate without any kind of limit/protection.
*edit* or was that someone else. Fairly sure some UG ( duathi = goblins) was pounding away on someone and i couldn't declare. Damn memory!
"Man will never be free until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest"
Contactable on gtalk & msn via sshagent @ gmail . com
Contactable on gtalk & msn via sshagent @ gmail . com
- Kaz
- Administrator
- Posts: 2614
- Joined: Thu Sep 24, 2009 1:27 am
- Location: The Vinyards of Fernabergia
- Tempers Ball Posts: 3873
- Tempers Ball/Braggarts Hall Alt: Kaz
- Contact:
Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)
As you point out in your edit, Dauthi isn't UG. So if it 'was' Dauthi, you could have declared Guild War on Goblins.
To a certain extent this thread seems to be complaining about something that 'might' happen, there are - after all - no UG suisorcs going around destroying guilded kingdoms. The UG Aey is having trouble with is actually big enough for Aey to declare war on and deal with 1 on 1.
Plus, as there is no downhit protection on unseen scum actions you can take down an UG even now, if you really want to.
Even though much of the complaints seem to be 'what if', there is - I suppose - a valid question to be asked. Do we really need UG's and shadow guilds in the Guilds game? Traditionally Shadow Guilds (Allied UG's) were officially against the rules (although not coded to prevent). We dropped that ruling with Unity and haven't included it here. But should we have done?
There is now code in place in the development client that 'could' resolve the matter in an instant.
Next age - if they are turned on - the down-hit declaration limitations will check to see if the kingdom you are declaring war on has recently attacked an ally, rather than just you. This in itself could enable smaller kingdoms having issues to ally up with a larger kingdom who could then retaliate.
Next age should also see the introduction of the restore feature. This will undo certain issues with regards to emotions tied to kingdoms being destroyed, but theoretically could open a whole new can of worms with regards to repeated targeting of players over time.
There is also optional code to attempt to enforce guilded or quaded play. Basically if that mode is enabled, when a guilded or quaded player (depending on game type) attempt to declare war on an UG the system would stop the declaration unless the UG has recently attacked the kingdom or his allies. If an UG attempts to declare war on any kingdom other than an NPC (unless the kingdom has recently attacked the UG or allies) the system would stop the declaration and suggest joining a guild or a quad.
That second bit of 'optional' code is a bit like taking a hammer to a theoretical problem, but on the flip-side there are really 4 types of UG.
1. Players who 'really' play UG for the challenge of knowing that they will be targeted a lot. A lot of players 'say' that they are this type of UG, but I think that many of them are actually type 2. This particular style doesn't really have a place in a game with down-hit protection.
2. Players who have gone UG as a result of guilded actions either this age or a previous age. They have gone UG for the specific purpose of causing problems for one (or a few) specific guilds or players.
3. These are not really a type on their own but are made up of players in groups 1 or 2 that want to carry out UG actions as a part of a shadow alliance.
4. Newbies who don't fully understand the game or the guild system.
To be perfectly honest, other than type 4 (who would be helped into a guild/quad by a message preventing them attacking alone), do we really gain any positive benefits from having the first 3 types of UG as options?
I think it's worth adding in Domination, but I'm currently on the fence with regards to adding the mode in Guilds. I can definitely see benefits, but then I can also see that it's fixing a problem that I'm not really sure exists at the moment.
To a certain extent this thread seems to be complaining about something that 'might' happen, there are - after all - no UG suisorcs going around destroying guilded kingdoms. The UG Aey is having trouble with is actually big enough for Aey to declare war on and deal with 1 on 1.
Plus, as there is no downhit protection on unseen scum actions you can take down an UG even now, if you really want to.
Even though much of the complaints seem to be 'what if', there is - I suppose - a valid question to be asked. Do we really need UG's and shadow guilds in the Guilds game? Traditionally Shadow Guilds (Allied UG's) were officially against the rules (although not coded to prevent). We dropped that ruling with Unity and haven't included it here. But should we have done?
There is now code in place in the development client that 'could' resolve the matter in an instant.
Next age - if they are turned on - the down-hit declaration limitations will check to see if the kingdom you are declaring war on has recently attacked an ally, rather than just you. This in itself could enable smaller kingdoms having issues to ally up with a larger kingdom who could then retaliate.
Next age should also see the introduction of the restore feature. This will undo certain issues with regards to emotions tied to kingdoms being destroyed, but theoretically could open a whole new can of worms with regards to repeated targeting of players over time.
There is also optional code to attempt to enforce guilded or quaded play. Basically if that mode is enabled, when a guilded or quaded player (depending on game type) attempt to declare war on an UG the system would stop the declaration unless the UG has recently attacked the kingdom or his allies. If an UG attempts to declare war on any kingdom other than an NPC (unless the kingdom has recently attacked the UG or allies) the system would stop the declaration and suggest joining a guild or a quad.
That second bit of 'optional' code is a bit like taking a hammer to a theoretical problem, but on the flip-side there are really 4 types of UG.
1. Players who 'really' play UG for the challenge of knowing that they will be targeted a lot. A lot of players 'say' that they are this type of UG, but I think that many of them are actually type 2. This particular style doesn't really have a place in a game with down-hit protection.
2. Players who have gone UG as a result of guilded actions either this age or a previous age. They have gone UG for the specific purpose of causing problems for one (or a few) specific guilds or players.
3. These are not really a type on their own but are made up of players in groups 1 or 2 that want to carry out UG actions as a part of a shadow alliance.
4. Newbies who don't fully understand the game or the guild system.
To be perfectly honest, other than type 4 (who would be helped into a guild/quad by a message preventing them attacking alone), do we really gain any positive benefits from having the first 3 types of UG as options?
I think it's worth adding in Domination, but I'm currently on the fence with regards to adding the mode in Guilds. I can definitely see benefits, but then I can also see that it's fixing a problem that I'm not really sure exists at the moment.
Programming is 10% science, 25% ingenuity and 65% getting the ingenuity to work with the science
Wars of Tonan (Monarchy Inspired Miniatures)
Armatures for Sculpting Miniatures
Wars of Tonan (Monarchy Inspired Miniatures)
Armatures for Sculpting Miniatures
- Jokingjoe
- Second Centurion
- Posts: 1204
- Joined: Fri Jan 22, 2010 7:35 pm
- Location: New Bern, NC
- Contact:
Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)
Uh oh, Aero, I think Kaz is on to us 
Re: UG Protection (split from numbers)
Kaz wrote:Next age - if they are turned on - the down-hit declaration limitations will check to see if the kingdom you are declaring war on has recently attacked an ally, rather than just you. This in itself could enable smaller kingdoms having issues to ally up with a larger kingdom who could then retaliate.
I like that. Cheers.
If word gets out that I'm missing, 500 girls will kill themselves and I wouldn't want them on my conscience - not when they ought to be on my face!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests