Page 1 of 2

UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 2:05 am
by Amb
Ok so.. I guess I need some advice on this situation I find myself in...

First, a little background. When I was 16 I was dating this guy.. first boyfriend and all that jazz. We didn't sleep together or any of that stuff, was just a first love kinda thing.. but I did love him. It ended up a long distance thing.. then, his parents ended up getting a divorce and he had a really bad time with that.. started acting out, getting into some bad shit and sleeping with another girl. I found out, and he started avoiding my calls, im's, emails.

Time goes on. I've gotten over it, completely forgiven him but still think of him every once in a while. We've talked once or twice over the ensuing 11yrs. Just old friend kinda stuff y'know?

Then comes this past December. For some reason he popped into my head, and I thought "hey.. wonder if he's on facebook?? I'll look him up". I found him and friended him. So a week later he accepts and seems surprised, yet happy to hear from me. In fact I got a "holy shit!!!!! how the hell have you been?????" We end up talking a little.. exchanging phone numbers and start texting. He went through some shit, but has straightened out his life after a rough road. And I am so proud of him for that! I used to worry he'd kill himself.

He has *always* been a flirt and that didn't change.. thing is, the more we txt the more I seem to think about him. And I didn't understand it.. why was I thinking about this guy?? why can't I get him out of my mind?? We're just friends.. what's going on?

We would txt off and on until about a month ago. Then it all kinda changed. He made some comment about how he hated to say it, but we were acting like we used to... 6hr txt conversation later, we've both admitted to feeling something for the other. Neither of us understands why or how something could have survived from that past relationship, but apparently it has. This month it's only seemed to get worse also. Between the phone calls and txts I don't even know how much time we've spent talking.. a LOT. And it's not just the flirty stuff anymore, he's told me about some of his dreams and we talk about how our days went.. normal relationship kinda stuff. We've talked about how it seems like we both needed to take the roads and learn the lessons we did to bring us to this place.. to maybe have another chance.

A week ago he drunk txted me. You know how they say people say things when they've been drinking that they otherwise wouldn't. He told me that when we were kids he really loved me, but he didn't know how to fix things after he fucked up.. and that he needs to make it better.. that he sees me everywhere he looks. That he thinks I could be his soulmate, but he's scared of letting go of what he has because he's afraid he won't make me happy. So this talk is when I pretty much knew that I was in love with him, I just won't admit it.

And love is where this gets tricky. He has a girlfriend. They've been together for a couple of years, and when straight up asked if he loves her, he said "at one point i did, now it's more of a friend thing". Now, I feel guilty that I feel the way I do about a guy who's with someone, but at the same time I can't help the way I feel about him. And I get it.. this probably makes me a really horrible person.. but if it takes being a horrible person to be with him, I think I'd do it.

Sooooooooo.. my question is.. do I just keep going along this road and see where it takes us??? Do I give him the time to figure out what he wants (because god knows, I understand being freaking confused about this whole deal!)? or do I just get the hell out of dodge and leave him be??

Thanks for anyone who actually read all that crap LMAO I think I just needed to say it all because I don't feel like I have anyone that I can really talk to about it :) It's too complicated.

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 2:13 am
by owly
There's nothing wrong with what you doing, if he gives up his current girlfriend for you you will know he loves you the same way you love him.......

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 2:21 am
by Venus
saying this and getting across what i mean is probalby not gonna work
but im gonna try


ive found that, with that one person who you REALLY loved, you always have to try a second time
because if u dont, then you will NEVER know if what u remember about them and feel about them is real, or if its just memories of how u wanted it to be...

i get the girlfriend thing etc. and that he may not know what he wants
but lets be honest here. this is about taking care of you first and foremost. You need to find a way to be with him honestly. Ideally it would work if he got rid of the girlfriend first, that way you will see if you really do still feel something for him, or if its just all the memories of first/only love etc.

once u get that out of the way, you might be surprised what you learn:>


and no, this doesnt make you a horrible person.

u can walk away, but chances are youll connect wiht him again eventually and find yourself in this same situation wondering what could have been.
you need to find out what could have been, in order to move on:>

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 2:47 am
by Amb
I think you said it very well Venus :) at least I pretty much understood exactly what you were saying.

He has always been my "what might have been", and I think you're right.. if I do walk away I'm going to be forever wondering until I'm in the same situation again.

I think it's just scary. Because what if it is all just memories/wishes.. and even scarier, what if it is the real thing???

I guess I just need to take it one day at a time for now. Give him time to get out of that relationship. Because I know it's not an easy thing to get yourself out of a long-term relationship. I think that's partly why I feel soooooo guilty. I was in her shoes once. I was completely in love with my boyfriend, who by that point only loved me as a friend, and I remember how it felt when he ended it for someone else. I understand now, but at the time it was horrible.

Thanks guys.. I needed someone to tell me I'm not horrible for feeling this way :)

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 3:01 am
by Venus
I think it's just scary. Because what if it is all just memories/wishes.. and even scarier, what if it is the real thing???
well if u wanna go with the soul mate thing, then here is what you will likely find if u discover its just memories and wishes.
you stay friends with them. because you cant not stay friends with them.
you discover you have that one person who is your friend for life. who always wants the best for you no matter what, and who will always be there if you REALLY REALLY need them.:)
but yet hes also the person who knows you better than anyone else:>

its a pretty good thing.
either way, its good for you:> and its better to know

because if its real. then its really really good to:>

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:02 am
by TEVA
I agree with Venus on this one. GO FOR ITyou have nothing tol lose.
Give him time to get out of the relationship he is in now.
Your not horrible person.

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 8:58 am
by MoP
Asking this community for advice? That desperate huh? ;)

I'll point Mickal en Reylan to this thread! They're experts!

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 1:15 pm
by Amb
MoP wrote:Asking this community for advice? That desperate huh? ;)

I'll point Mickal en Reylan to this thread! They're experts!
ROFL yeah, you know you're kinda desperate when this is where you turn for advice.. ;) but then some of the people here are like family! (maybe long-lost family at times, but family all the same)

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 2:34 pm
by Grunt
My only problem is this
He cheated on you before
He does not seem to have a problem cheating on his current GF
He will eventually cheat again

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:01 pm
by Reylan Talonspyre
I concur with Grunt.

You need a new man. The fact you can't have him is making you want him more. I have been there, I am almost always like that with women. The moment I can get them, BAM, I am not so interested.

It is why I go after women with boyfriends.

I fail and therefore can maintain my current nerd-life without regret.

My advice: you should not be me. You are a woman and women have vaginas (stick with me here). Vagina can make men do great and terrible things (i.e. invade Troy, make the movie Twilight, etc.). Now, if you have said weapon of man destruction (WMD), use it sparingly and pick a new man to throw yourself on. Or just play the field. There will be others. Probably a lot of others.

I say date someone you wouldn't normally date.

Now, can we please see pics?

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:05 pm
by owly
i had a couple of chances to cheat on my girl friend bur i never did, i love for Hatama to much, besides sex with Hatama is amazing,........

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:15 pm
by Venus
yeah but the whole point of it is to get rid of the "what might have been " part
even if she gets hurt, she will know the answer to that.

believe me, what might have been can drive u insane.
its better to know, even if u get hurt.
it makes things a little easier to move on and take a new road...so to speak.

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:24 pm
by Amb
Technically no cheating has occurred right now.. we've talked, that is all and I have always been of the opinion "you can look but you can't touch" and as no touching has happened I don't feel like it's cheating. And yeah, he cheated on me.. but he was 15yr old. Seriously boys.. how many of you wouldn't have jumped at the chance to sleep with almost any girl at that age??

I dunno.. I'm still gonna stick with Venus' advice and just see what happens.. give him time to get out of the relationship he's in. If I give him that time and he makes no move to change that relationship then I move on.
Venus wrote:yeah but the whole point of it is to get rid of the "what might have been " part
even if she gets hurt, she will know the answer to that.

believe me, what might have been can drive u insane.
its better to know, even if u get hurt.
it makes things a little easier to move on and take a new road...so to speak.
She hit the nail on the head! I'd rather know for sure, even if it hurts in the end than to forever wonder!!
Reylan Talonspyre wrote:My advice: you should not be me. You are a woman and women have vaginas (stick with me here). Vagina can make men do great and terrible things (i.e. invade Troy, make the movie Twilight, etc.). Now, if you have said weapon of man destruction (WMD), use it sparingly and pick a new man to throw yourself on.
ROFL that was just awesome.. I don't really know what else to say to that.. I love it ;)
Reylan Talonspyre wrote: Now, can we please see pics?
would that be pics of me? or of him? LOL :P

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:26 pm
by owly
Grunt had a good point

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 5:53 pm
by Amb
Me:

Image

Image


Him:

Image

Image

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:17 pm
by Bogumil
How often do you get a second chance on something that matters?

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:34 pm
by owly
i'm so fuck up right now i'm having a hard time typing.......

Take it slow Amb when you go out for your first date with him you'll know if he's your soul mate, or not.........

No matter what happens i wish you happiness :mrgreen: :geek: 8-) :evil:

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:39 pm
by Amb
owly wrote:i'm so fuck up right now i'm having a hard time typing.......
is this unusual?? :mrgreen: LOL sorry, couldn't resist!

Thanks owly! I'm definitely going to take my time on this.. not something I want to rush.

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:46 pm
by Venus
damn u could have just led with the picture of him and i would have told u to go for it
we coulda just bypassed all that typing stuff:Ppp


as for cheating when he was 15? hell ive got a 14 year old, hed cheat with a pile of cheese as long as it convinced him it was a girl

i dont think cheating on u when he was 15 even counts lol

Re: UGH!! why do things have to be complicated??

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:47 pm
by Venus
on a side note, owly have u ALREADY went out and got the absinthe? lol