the false premise of high defence races
Posted: Sat Mar 29, 2014 4:49 pm
this segues somewhat with an ongoing discussion ensuring that all races are useful, but i wanted to post this in a location that is easier for people to access. i debated posting this in NPA, but since many players don't seem to read NPA (despite the high-quality posts that are being made there), and the fact that this is a discussion about higher-level play and game mechanics, i figured i'd post it here.
as i outline in my basic game tips thread (a thread that most GMs seem to be ignoring, to their detriment, as i've noticed several GMs make basic game mechanics mistakes since the start of this age that are covered in this thread), tip #11 outlines my philosophy on forting/reforting. whether you follow my suggestion or not, it is a fact that all kingdoms mix scum and troops when forting defence.
i've played elemental realms on and off for the last two ages, most recently with 1 of my 4 in domination. i thought it would be useful to have a high-offense, high-sorc realm for early and mid-game play. in end-game play, my intuition was that they would be decent, but not the best. principally, its gr defence is decent (value defence 24.00), but it also has the option of "quick" switching to high t4 offense (minimal turns required for training).
the other three realms in my quad are 1 sidhe, and 2 humans. from the beginning, i planned that my two humans would be my principal end-game kingdoms. my intuition - which i've posted in other discussions - is that humans are among the most versatile kingdoms in the early- and mid-game, and that their survivability in end-game scenarios is quite high, relatively speaking.
recent reforts in the 22k-23k range have given me further pause for thought. given that human scum costs substantially less than elemental scum (1650 vs. 1950 gold), humans are able to hold more defensive troops at the same level of scum. despite the fact that elemental t3 value defence is higher than human t3 or t2 value defence (26.00 vs. 22.00 and 24.00), while elemental t1 value defense is higher than human t3 and equal to human t2 (24.00 vs. 22.00 and 24.00), the question becomes one of at which level of scum do human realms start to actually be able to defend better than elemental realms?
out comes the handy spreadsheet. the actual number of scum at which this switch occurs - at which human realms have a higher defence defence than elemental realms - is dependent on troop cap size. since i was principally concerned with end-game kingdoms, i arbitrarily chose 60mil as the troop cap. of greater importance, though, is the table to the right of that: the scum to troop cap percentage (aka ratio), whose figures are independent of the size of a kingdom's troop cap.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B60rkR ... hOTDQyRmM/
i focused on 4 scenarios which compare human vs. elemental races:
-scenario 1: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t3 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t2
-scenario 2: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t1 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t2
-scenario 3: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t3 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t3
-scenario 4: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t1 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t3
notes:
-i assume that the player maxes out on troops.
-the calculations are derived principally for csing/FAing.
-forts are excluded from this analysis, but human forts are stronger than elemental forts. the difference is relatively negligeable, though.
the two most important scenarios are likely scenarios 2 and 3, and to some extent scenario 1. scenarios 2 and 3 are much better comparisons between elemental and human races in terms of the number of turns required. scenario 1 is comparable only insofar as the player is going for the best defence possible.
i'll speak briefly to scenario 2, which is a special case scenario that is most applicable to end-game scenarios when high GR defence is crucial. what the calculations demonstrate is that humans will always have better defence than elemental kingdoms when forting for GR defence, no matter how much scum is higher. as long as there's more than zero scum, humans will always have better GR defence because the value defence for elemental t1/scum and human t2/scum are equal (24.00/15.00), but humans can always hire more scum than elemental realms because of the cheaper cost (1650 vs. 1950).
going back to that table on the right, let's look at scenario 3, which is most applicable to early- and some mid-game kingdoms. what this table says is that, at any given kingdom size, when an elemental is forting t3 and spends more than 54.2% of its troop cap on scum, its defence will be lower than a human forting t3 with the same quantity of scum (equivalent to 45.8% of the human kingdom's troop cap).
this is a rough estimate, but it says that an ele realm that is running approx 11k scum (with the rest t3) on 24k acres is going to be have defence equivalent to a 24k human kingdom that is also running 11k scum (with the rest t3).
for every other troop combination, though, elementals get decimated. a 24k human forting t2 will have higher defence than a 24k elemental kingdom if the kingdoms are forting more than 7.1k scum.
i think we can all agree that 7.1k scum is insufficient to defend a 24k kingdom. ergo, elemental kingdoms are much weaker than human kingdoms in most mid-game scenarios, provided that human realms have a good enough train rate to train t2. in all end-game scenarios, where an elemental kingdom would actually need a higher train rate to keep up with the human realm, humans easily outclass elementals in all aspects.
there is a minor trade-off, of course: human t2 take 2.55x more turns to train (5100 gold vs. 2000 gold), so the intangible here is that an elemental realm gets another 6-10 turns at 24k land with which to build, depending on the train rate. over the course of 4-5 turnsets, that can add up quickly to upwards of 50 turns. at 16 brt, that's 800 structures.
BUT, the additional upshot for humans is that not only is their defence better, they can hold more scum than elementals. so not only is their defence better, but so is their scum offensive capability.
all in all, this post is a cautionary note about the false premise that races with high defence (4/5 or 5/5) will necessarily have higher defence than races with lower defence (3/5). indeed, you may note that sidhe have the exact same t2 value defence (24.00) and scum cost (1650) as humans - so their end-game survivability is just as good, although their offence is incredibly weak, so getting them to that level is going to be a lot more difficult. sidhe sorc is so powerful, though, that i think they're a fantastic race to have in your arsenal.
here is the spreadsheet in case you want to fool around with the troop cap size (the file format is .ods, which is open office). the only thing you need to do is change the value of cell B2 (which i've highlighted in red), and the spreadsheet will spit out new numbers for you. i've also updated the spreadsheet to include a backwards-calculated approximate kingdom size, based on troop cap of 1628 gold per acre. this was off of a relatively low-barracks kingdom, so the actual quantity of gold you get per acre should be higher (i think it's above 1650 gold per acre with something like 25%-35% rax, but anyways...).
as i outline in my basic game tips thread (a thread that most GMs seem to be ignoring, to their detriment, as i've noticed several GMs make basic game mechanics mistakes since the start of this age that are covered in this thread), tip #11 outlines my philosophy on forting/reforting. whether you follow my suggestion or not, it is a fact that all kingdoms mix scum and troops when forting defence.
i've played elemental realms on and off for the last two ages, most recently with 1 of my 4 in domination. i thought it would be useful to have a high-offense, high-sorc realm for early and mid-game play. in end-game play, my intuition was that they would be decent, but not the best. principally, its gr defence is decent (value defence 24.00), but it also has the option of "quick" switching to high t4 offense (minimal turns required for training).
the other three realms in my quad are 1 sidhe, and 2 humans. from the beginning, i planned that my two humans would be my principal end-game kingdoms. my intuition - which i've posted in other discussions - is that humans are among the most versatile kingdoms in the early- and mid-game, and that their survivability in end-game scenarios is quite high, relatively speaking.
recent reforts in the 22k-23k range have given me further pause for thought. given that human scum costs substantially less than elemental scum (1650 vs. 1950 gold), humans are able to hold more defensive troops at the same level of scum. despite the fact that elemental t3 value defence is higher than human t3 or t2 value defence (26.00 vs. 22.00 and 24.00), while elemental t1 value defense is higher than human t3 and equal to human t2 (24.00 vs. 22.00 and 24.00), the question becomes one of at which level of scum do human realms start to actually be able to defend better than elemental realms?
out comes the handy spreadsheet. the actual number of scum at which this switch occurs - at which human realms have a higher defence defence than elemental realms - is dependent on troop cap size. since i was principally concerned with end-game kingdoms, i arbitrarily chose 60mil as the troop cap. of greater importance, though, is the table to the right of that: the scum to troop cap percentage (aka ratio), whose figures are independent of the size of a kingdom's troop cap.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B60rkR ... hOTDQyRmM/
i focused on 4 scenarios which compare human vs. elemental races:
-scenario 1: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t3 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t2
-scenario 2: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t1 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t2
-scenario 3: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t3 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t3
-scenario 4: an elemental kingdom fortifying on scum & t1 vs. a human kingdom fortifying on scum & t3
notes:
-i assume that the player maxes out on troops.
-the calculations are derived principally for csing/FAing.
-forts are excluded from this analysis, but human forts are stronger than elemental forts. the difference is relatively negligeable, though.
the two most important scenarios are likely scenarios 2 and 3, and to some extent scenario 1. scenarios 2 and 3 are much better comparisons between elemental and human races in terms of the number of turns required. scenario 1 is comparable only insofar as the player is going for the best defence possible.
i'll speak briefly to scenario 2, which is a special case scenario that is most applicable to end-game scenarios when high GR defence is crucial. what the calculations demonstrate is that humans will always have better defence than elemental kingdoms when forting for GR defence, no matter how much scum is higher. as long as there's more than zero scum, humans will always have better GR defence because the value defence for elemental t1/scum and human t2/scum are equal (24.00/15.00), but humans can always hire more scum than elemental realms because of the cheaper cost (1650 vs. 1950).
going back to that table on the right, let's look at scenario 3, which is most applicable to early- and some mid-game kingdoms. what this table says is that, at any given kingdom size, when an elemental is forting t3 and spends more than 54.2% of its troop cap on scum, its defence will be lower than a human forting t3 with the same quantity of scum (equivalent to 45.8% of the human kingdom's troop cap).
this is a rough estimate, but it says that an ele realm that is running approx 11k scum (with the rest t3) on 24k acres is going to be have defence equivalent to a 24k human kingdom that is also running 11k scum (with the rest t3).
for every other troop combination, though, elementals get decimated. a 24k human forting t2 will have higher defence than a 24k elemental kingdom if the kingdoms are forting more than 7.1k scum.
i think we can all agree that 7.1k scum is insufficient to defend a 24k kingdom. ergo, elemental kingdoms are much weaker than human kingdoms in most mid-game scenarios, provided that human realms have a good enough train rate to train t2. in all end-game scenarios, where an elemental kingdom would actually need a higher train rate to keep up with the human realm, humans easily outclass elementals in all aspects.
there is a minor trade-off, of course: human t2 take 2.55x more turns to train (5100 gold vs. 2000 gold), so the intangible here is that an elemental realm gets another 6-10 turns at 24k land with which to build, depending on the train rate. over the course of 4-5 turnsets, that can add up quickly to upwards of 50 turns. at 16 brt, that's 800 structures.
BUT, the additional upshot for humans is that not only is their defence better, they can hold more scum than elementals. so not only is their defence better, but so is their scum offensive capability.
all in all, this post is a cautionary note about the false premise that races with high defence (4/5 or 5/5) will necessarily have higher defence than races with lower defence (3/5). indeed, you may note that sidhe have the exact same t2 value defence (24.00) and scum cost (1650) as humans - so their end-game survivability is just as good, although their offence is incredibly weak, so getting them to that level is going to be a lot more difficult. sidhe sorc is so powerful, though, that i think they're a fantastic race to have in your arsenal.
here is the spreadsheet in case you want to fool around with the troop cap size (the file format is .ods, which is open office). the only thing you need to do is change the value of cell B2 (which i've highlighted in red), and the spreadsheet will spit out new numbers for you. i've also updated the spreadsheet to include a backwards-calculated approximate kingdom size, based on troop cap of 1628 gold per acre. this was off of a relatively low-barracks kingdom, so the actual quantity of gold you get per acre should be higher (i think it's above 1650 gold per acre with something like 25%-35% rax, but anyways...).